Wood is not the only practical heat source for a cabin or rural home. Propane, heat pumps, heating oil and wood pellets each suit different properties, depending on fuel delivery, available electricity and how often the building is occupied. This guide compares their energy content and running cost with arithmetic you can repeat using local prices, explains what each system needs to run, covers the installation codes and storage rules, and shows why electricity supply decides which options work off the grid.
Comparing fuels by energy content
To compare fuels sold in different units, convert each to the heat it delivers inside the building. That depends on the energy in each unit of fuel and the seasonal efficiency of the appliance burning it.
| Fuel | Energy content (NRCan) |
|---|---|
| Propane | 25.3 MJ/L (about 90,800 BTU per US gal) |
| Heating oil | 38.2 MJ/L (about 137,000 BTU per US gal) |
| Wood pellets | 19,800 MJ/tonne, or 19.8 MJ/kg (about 8,500 BTU/lb) |
| Electricity | 3.6 MJ/kWh (3,412 BTU/kWh) |
| Hardwood, full cord | 30,600 MJ |
| Softwood, full cord | 18,700 MJ |
Seasonal efficiency is the share of the fuel's energy that ends up as heat in the house over a full heating season, rated as annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) for furnaces and boilers. Electric resistance heat is 100% efficient at the point of use. A heat pump delivers more heat than the electricity it uses; its ratio of heat out to electricity in is the coefficient of performance (COP).
Cost per GJ delivered = price per unit ÷ (energy per unit in GJ × efficiency)
For electricity, use 0.0036 GJ per kWh and replace efficiency with the COP of a heat pump, or 1.0 for resistance heat.
Worked example: cost per gigajoule of delivered heat
The prices below are examples for the arithmetic only. Substitute the prices your suppliers quote, including delivery charges and tank rental.
- Propane at $0.90/L in a 92% condensing furnace: 0.90 ÷ (0.0253 × 0.92) = 0.90 ÷ 0.0233 = $38.67/GJ
- Heating oil at $1.60/L in an 85% furnace: 1.60 ÷ (0.0382 × 0.85) = 1.60 ÷ 0.0325 = $49.28/GJ
- Pellets at $400/tonne ($0.40/kg) in an 80% stove: 0.40 ÷ (0.0198 × 0.80) = 0.40 ÷ 0.0158 = $25.25/GJ
- Grid electricity at $0.15/kWh, resistance heat: 0.15 ÷ 0.0036 = $41.67/GJ
- The same electricity in a heat pump with a seasonal COP of 2.0: 41.67 ÷ 2.0 = $20.83/GJ
Multiply the cost per GJ by the building's annual heat demand to get a yearly fuel bill. A house needing 40 GJ of delivered heat would spend 40 × $38.67 = $1,547 on propane at these example prices.
Worked example: how much fuel to store
The same 40 GJ of delivered heat requires:
- Propane at 92%: 40 ÷ (0.0253 × 0.92) = 1,718 L (454 US gal)
- Heating oil at 85%: 40 ÷ (0.0382 × 0.85) = 1,232 L (325 US gal)
- Pellets at 80%: 40 ÷ (0.0198 × 0.80) = 2,525 kg, or about 2.5 tonnes (2.8 short tons)
- Electricity, resistance: 40 ÷ 0.0036 = 11,111 kWh
- Electricity, heat pump at seasonal COP 1.5: 11,111 ÷ 1.5 = 7,407 kWh
On a property with fuel delivery only in summer, or a road closed in spring, storage must hold the whole season's fuel plus a margin for a cold winter.
Estimate annual heat demand from the building's heat-loss rate and local heating degree-days, as shown in our guides to wood heat and the building envelope, or from past fuel records.
Propane
Propane is stored as a liquid under pressure in a tank or cylinders outside the building and burns as a gas. It suits properties without natural gas, needs no daily handling, and can run furnaces, boilers, wall heaters, water heaters, ranges and generators from one supply.
Appliance efficiency
NRCan publishes these seasonal efficiency ranges for propane equipment:
| Propane appliance | Seasonal efficiency (AFUE) |
|---|---|
| Conventional furnace or boiler (older) | 62% |
| Standard-efficiency furnace | 79–85% |
| Standard-efficiency boiler | 82–90% |
| Condensing furnace | 88–95% |
| Condensing boiler | 87–97% |
Federal Energy Efficiency Regulations require new gas furnaces sold in Canada to be at least 90% efficient and residential gas boilers to have an AFUE of at least 82%. For direct-vent wall furnaces, NRCan gives a general range of 70 to 82% for gas units.
Venting and combustion air
Sealed-combustion (two-pipe) condensing appliances draw combustion air from outdoors through one pipe and exhaust through another, usually plastic, that must slope as the manufacturer specifies so condensate drains. Sealed combustion is the better choice for a tight building because the appliance does not take air from the room. Keep vent terminals clear of snow, ice and drifting; a blocked terminal shuts the appliance down or spills exhaust. Older chimneys may need an approved metal liner before venting a new gas appliance.
Electricity needs
Furnaces need electricity for the blower, inducer fan and controls, and boilers for circulator pumps and controls. If power fails, they stop. Some direct-vent wall heaters run their burner and thermostat without household power and rely on natural convection; others have fans and electronic ignition. Read the specification sheet for electrical draw before buying for an off-grid building, and size the inverter and batteries for the blower's running and starting load.
Cold weather
Propane boils at about −42 °C (−44 °F). As the tank gets colder, the pressure inside drops and the tank produces vapour more slowly. A small tank or cylinder supplying a large furnace in deep cold can fail to keep up even when it holds plenty of liquid. Your supplier sizes the tank for the appliance load and the local climate; tell them the total input rating of every appliance connected.
Heat pumps
A heat pump moves heat from outdoor air, or from the ground, into the building. Because it moves heat rather than making it, it can deliver two to three units of heat per unit of electricity in mild weather. Output and efficiency fall as the outdoor temperature drops.
What NRCan reports
- Standard air-source heat pumps can be up to 2.5 times more efficient than an oil furnace or boiler, but may need supplemental heat when outdoor temperatures fall to between −10 and −15 °C.
- Cold-climate air-source heat pumps can operate at outdoor temperatures as low as −30 °C, with efficiencies up to 3 times that of an oil furnace or boiler. Below −30 °C they need supplemental heat.
- Ground-source heat pumps can reach up to 3.5 times the efficiency of an oil furnace or boiler. Design and installation must follow CSA C448.
Field results in a cold climate
The Yukon government monitored five cold-climate air-source heat pumps in homes over several winters. In the 2022–2023 season:
- Seasonal COP ranged from 1.10 to 2.51 across the five units. All had a seasonal COP above 1.
- All units ran down to −29 °C, but at COPs below 1 at the coldest temperatures; the units were designed to switch to backup heat at about −29 °C.
- The temperature below which electric resistance backup became more efficient than the heat pump ranged from −11 °C for the poorest unit to −28 °C for the best.
- Defrost used 2.7 to 7.7% of each unit's electricity.
- Only one of the five units reached the airflow the manufacturer suggested; the report identifies undersized ducts as the likely cause and makes duct design by a qualified sheet metal worker the first priority.
The report also recommends against oversizing, suggests ductless mini-splits where ducts cannot be enlarged, and advises placing outdoor units away from bedrooms, structurally separate from the house, with drainage and shelter from ice build-up.
Sizing and the balance point
NRCan's Air-Source Heat Pump Sizing and Selection Guide describes plotting the building's heat load against outdoor temperature as a straight line, from the full design heating load at the design temperature down to zero load at 16 °C (60 °F). The heat pump's capacity curve falls as temperature drops. The point where the two lines cross is the balance point: above it the heat pump carries the load alone, and below it backup heat makes up the difference. Manufacturers publish extended performance tables showing capacity and COP at low temperatures; use those, not the nameplate rating at 8 °C (47 °F).
Worked example: a heat pump on an off-grid battery bank
A cabin has a design heat load of 5 kW at −25 °C. Assume a COP of 1.5 at that temperature, which is better than most units in the Yukon study achieved.
Electrical input: 5 kW ÷ 1.5 = 3.3 kW. Over 24 hours: 3.3 × 24 = 80 kWh per day.
A 20 kWh battery bank would carry that load for 20 ÷ 3.3 = about 6 hours, and the cold, short days that produce this load are also the days with the least solar input. Even at a milder −5 °C, with about half the load (2.5 kW) and an assumed COP of 2.5, the heat pump needs 1 kW, or 24 kWh per day.
For most off-grid buildings, a heat pump works as a shoulder-season or daytime heat source when solar output is high, with a fuel-burning appliance carrying the deep-winter load. On the grid, the arithmetic is different and a heat pump is often the lowest-cost option per GJ.
Heating oil
Oil holds more energy per litre than propane and is stored on site in one tank. Its drawbacks are leak risk, annual servicing, and burner and fan electricity.
Efficiency
NRCan gives these seasonal efficiencies for oil equipment: old cast-iron head burners about 60%; flame-retention head replacement burners 70 to 78%; new standard models 78 to 86%; mid-efficiency furnaces 83 to 89%; condensing furnaces 90% or more. Since 1998, Canadian regulations have required new oil furnaces to reach at least 78% AFUE, and since September 2010 new oil boilers at least 84%.
A professional cleaning and tune-up at least once a year, before the heating season, keeps efficiency up. NRCan gives a normal flue gas temperature range of about 175 to 280 °C; a rise of 25 °C above normal indicates about 3% efficiency loss and a need for service.
Tanks and the installation code
Oil equipment in Canada is installed to the CSA B139 series. Part B139.2 covers residential and small commercial buildings, up to 3 storeys and 600 m², with individual supply tanks up to 2,500 L (550 imperial gal) and a total of 5,000 L (1,100 imperial gal) per property. Requirements in the 2019 edition of the series include:
- single-wall steel tanks installed outdoors need secondary containment or a double bottom with interstitial monitoring;
- new tanks and connections must be leak-tested by the installer;
- tanks to be inspected annually;
- a minimum clearance of 1.5 m (5 ft) from doors, windows and exits, and a replacement outdoor tank may not sit on the property line;
- fill and vent pipes must slope 1/4 in per foot (about 20 mm per metre) and vent caps must be screened.
Insurer guidance from Co-operators adds practical points: an indoor tank is preferable because it is protected from ice, snow and frost heave; indoor tanks must be at least 0.6 m (2 ft) from fuel-fired appliances unless separated by a non-combustible wall; outdoor tanks need a solid non-combustible base such as a concrete slab, and setbacks of at least 30 m (100 ft) from open water and 9 m (30 ft) from a drilled well, ditch, storm drain or septic bed. Choose a new tank approved to ULC standards, never a used or rebuilt one, and keep it near full in summer to limit condensation and rust.
Wood pellets
Pellets are compressed sawdust burned in a stove, insert, furnace or boiler with an automatic feed. A motor-driven auger feeds pellets from a hopper to a burn pot at a rate set by the controls, and fans supply combustion air and circulate heat. The result is steady, thermostat-controlled wood heat with far less handling than cordwood.
- Energy: 19.8 MJ/kg. A 2.5 tonne season's supply, from the example above, is about 125 bags of 20 kg (44 lb).
- Storage: pellets must stay dry; damp pellets swell, crumble and jam the auger. Store them indoors or under cover, off the floor.
- Electricity: the auger, fans, controls and igniter all need power, and the igniter draws much more than the running load while it operates. A pellet stove stops when power fails, so on an off-grid system include its consumption in the daily load and the igniter in the inverter sizing, using the manufacturer's figures.
- Venting: pellet appliances use pellet vent listed to ULC-S609 in Canada and are installed to CSA B365, the installation code for solid-fuel-burning appliances. Follow the manufacturer's listed clearances and vent configuration.
- Supply: check that more than one supplier can deliver your pellet grade before relying on pellets as the main heat source.
Electric resistance heat
Baseboards and electric furnaces turn every kilowatt-hour into 3.6 MJ of heat with no venting, fuel storage or maintenance. On the grid they cost more to run than a heat pump on the same power. Off the grid, the arithmetic rules them out as a main heat source: the 40 GJ example needs 11,111 kWh a year, concentrated in the months with least solar output. A small thermostatic heater that keeps a pump room or water tank above freezing, run from surplus solar or a generator, is the realistic off-grid use.
Choosing and combining systems
| System | Needs electricity to run | Fuel storage | Main installation code or standard (Canada) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Propane furnace or boiler | Yes: blower or circulator, controls | Outdoor tank or cylinders | Gas installation code; licensed gas contractor |
| Propane direct-vent wall heater | Depends on model | Outdoor tank or cylinders | Gas installation code; licensed gas contractor |
| Air-source heat pump | Yes: compressor, fans, defrost | None | Electrical code; qualified contractor |
| Ground-source heat pump | Yes: compressor, loop pumps | None | CSA C448 |
| Oil furnace or boiler | Yes: burner, blower or circulator | Indoor or outdoor tank | CSA B139 |
| Pellet stove or boiler | Yes: auger, fans, igniter | Dry indoor or covered storage | CSA B365; ULC-S609 vent |
| Electric resistance | Yes, entirely | None | Electrical code |
Most rural buildings are best served by two heat sources. Common combinations are:
- Wood stove plus propane wall heater: wood for the main load; propane keeps the building above freezing when nobody is there to load the stove, with no electricity if a no-power model is chosen.
- Heat pump plus wood or propane: the heat pump carries mild weather and sunny days; the fuel appliance takes over below the balance point and during power shortages.
- Oil or propane boiler plus wood: the boiler gives automatic heat and hot water; wood reduces fuel purchases.
For a seasonal cabin left unheated in winter, a low-temperature setting on a reliable appliance protects plumbing if the building must stay above freezing; otherwise the water system must be drained, as described in our water systems guide.
Safety, alarms and permits
- Carbon monoxide alarms: every fuel-burning appliance can produce carbon monoxide. Install alarms certified to CAN/CSA-6.19 near fuel-fired appliances and near sleeping areas. Early symptoms of CO poisoning resemble flu: headache, tiredness and nausea. If an alarm sounds, leave the building and call for help from outside.
- Smoke alarms: install alarms certified to CAN/ULC-S531 on every level and near sleeping areas. On off-grid power, choose models with sealed long-life batteries or battery backup.
- Vent terminals and air intakes: check them after every heavy snowfall and ice storm.
- Annual service: have oil, propane and pellet appliances cleaned and checked by a qualified technician every year.
- Permits: installing or replacing a furnace, boiler, tank or heat pump may need gas, electrical, building or mechanical permits. Requirements differ between provinces, states and municipalities; NRCan advises that the contract state who obtains them.
- Insurance: tell your insurer about any new heating appliance or fuel tank before using it.
Key points
- Compare fuels by cost per GJ delivered: price ÷ (energy content in GJ × efficiency). Propane holds 25.3 MJ/L, oil 38.2 MJ/L, pellets 19.8 MJ/kg and electricity 3.6 MJ/kWh.
- Store enough fuel for the whole season where delivery is seasonal; 40 GJ of heat takes about 1,700 L of propane, 1,200 L of oil or 2.5 tonnes of pellets.
- New gas furnaces must be at least 90% efficient in Canada. Use sealed-combustion appliances in tight buildings and keep vent terminals clear of snow.
- Cold-climate heat pumps run to about −30 °C, but field results show COPs near or below 1 in deep cold. Off the grid they suit mild weather and sunny days, not the winter peak.
- Oil tanks follow CSA B139: inspect annually, use secondary containment outdoors, and keep tanks well away from wells and open water.
- Pellet stoves need electricity for the auger, fans and igniter, and stop when power fails.
- Install CO alarms, service fuel appliances yearly, use licensed installers, and get permits where required.
This guide is general information. Codes, permits and safety requirements vary by province, state and municipality. Check local rules and use a qualified professional for electrical, gas, chimney and septic work where required.
The Comprehensive Off-Grid Manual
Every off-grid system in one manual, with worked examples, checklists and northern-climate detail.
More guides
Heating with Wood: Stoves, Firewood and Safety
Choose and size a certified wood stove, meet clearance and chimney rules, calculate cords per winter, burn cleanly and prevent chimney fires.
Off-Grid Solar Power: How to Size a System
Size an off-grid solar system for Canadian winters: load audit, peak sun hours, array, MPPT, inverter, wiring, fusing, with a full cabin example.
Off-Grid Batteries: LiFePO4 vs Lead-Acid
LiFePO4 vs lead-acid for off-grid power: usable capacity, cycle life, cold-weather charging, bank sizing, wiring, ventilation and lifetime cost.